A new tv production will premiere on the Oxygen Network about a series of murder cases that have become more legend than reality in the Historic Triangle.
The two-day event, “Lover’s Lane Murders,” is a four-episode series on the locally infamous Colonial Parkway murders.
The Colonial Parkway murders were a series of four double homicides from 1986-89. Each homicide occurred somewhere along the Colonial Parkway, hence the colloquial name.
The eeriest part, however, is how the case is still unsolved.
The show features former FBI profiler Jim Clemente, former FBI agent Maureen O’Connell, former prosecutor Loni Coombs, and forensic expert Dr. Laura Pettler.
Bill Thomas, a music executive who lives in Connecticut, had an active role as a consulting producer and the show’s “subject matter expert.”
Thomas also runs a true crime podcast with local high school English teacher, Kristin Dilley. Their podcast is called “Mind over Murder,” and was originally created to cover true crime stories and raise awareness about unsolved cases.
But when Thomas became involved with the Oxygen Network’s show, he and Dilley decided to wait until the show came out to discuss the Colonial Parkway murders on their podcast.
Thomas has a unique connection to the Colonial Parkway murders — his sister, Cathleen Thomas, and her girlfriend, Rebecca Dowski, were the first two victims.
For the show, Thomas helped facilitate interviews and reached out to former investigators, journalists, and family members of the victims to see if they would participate. During the interview filming process, Thomas would sit off camera and listen to answers for accuracy.
“When you’re talking about four double homicides in a case that’s stretched over all of these years, it gets really complicated,” Thomas said. “So my job was to listen to their answers and correct errors.”
Local viewers of the show might even recognize some of the places where filming took place. Thomas said many of the shots were taken along the Colonial Parkway to give the show a more “local flavor.” For interior shots, the production team used a warehouse in Richmond, but most filming took place in the Tidewater area.
“When we ran into people in town, we never told people what we were working on,” he said, adding he and the crew would simply answer it was a documentary.
And this was true, in a way.
“If you mention ‘I’m doing a show on the Colonial Parkway murders,’ then everyone wants to give their input or share theories, and that takes up a lot of time,” Thomas said.
The show has been a work in progress for four years, and Thomas said the show was in the final stages of editing right before the pandemic began.
The most difficult part, however, may have been convincing family members to participate in the project at all. Thomas said he had to do a lot of convincing to get people to talk on camera.
“Most people don’t like being interviewed on television to start with, and then they’re being asked to talk about what, for many of us, is the most painful day of our lives,” Thomas said.
Even though Thomas has a personal connection to the Colonial Parkway cases, he can casually talk about the case to anyone willing to listen. He said it’s a combination of being in the media industry for so long and his longing for answers.
“It’s something I’ve gotten comfortable doing,” Thomas said. “I can always emphasize with people who have lost loved ones.”
“At the same time, we as families feel that it’s very important to keep a focus on the Colonial Parkway murders and keep doing interviews and talking about it,” he added.
And perhaps by continuing to raise awareness about the murders, Thomas and many other families can find the answers they’ve been searching after for the past 34 years.
In the meantime, the other question seems to be why the network decided to go with a different name for the show than the colloquial one given to the murder cases.
Maybe by watching, viewers can find out.
“Lover’s Lane Murders” premieres Friday, Feb 11. at 9 p.m. You can see the trailer for the show below, courtesy of Oxygen.
Four double homicides in four years. Is there a serial killer on Lovers’ Lane? @Oxygen‘s two-night special #LoversLaneMurders premieres Thursday, February 11 at 8/7c. Drop a “❤️” in the comments if you can’t wait. pic.twitter.com/A4HdIFHF0Y
— Oxygen (@oxygen) January 19, 2021
For more information, click here to see the network’s show schedule.
YOU MIGHT WANT TO CHECK OUT THESE STORIES:
- Vaccinations move to Phase 1b in the Historic Triangle. Here’s what localities are doing to help
- Williamsburg Crossing Bruster’s ice cream shop may soon have a drive-thru
- JCC Planning commission approves special-use permit for Williamsburg landscaping business
- Peninsula Health District expands COVID-19 vaccinations to ‘Phase 1b’ priority recipients
- WJCC Schools delays hybrid learning to mid-February
- Man charged for allegedly sodomizing teen, YPSO says
- Ex-Ford’s Colony co-owner indicted on bank fraud
- Q&A with W&M professor on First Amendment freedoms and limitations
- The George Washington Inn and Conference Center will be turned into a 125-unit rental apartment building
- Phase 2 of the First Baptist Church archaeological project begins; foundations donate millions