When most ships see an ice floe, they flee.
Not so the Swedish research vessel Oden, which this month will moor itself to a large slab of floating Arctic ice for a study of one of the major uncertainties in climate-change research — the complex interplay between sea and sky.
Joining the international project is a three-member team from William & Mary’s Virginia Institute of Marine Science.
Assistant professor Elizabeth Shadwick, the VIMS lead, will contribute from stateside as she recently returned from maternity leave. Professor Walker Smith and postdoctoral researcher Andrew Margolin will travel aboard the 354-foot icebreaker Oden, which sailed north from Svalbard on July 31.
Shadwick said her team’s objective “is to assess how changes in seawater chemistry as a result of increases in atmospheric carbon dioxide will alter interactions between algae and bacteria in sea ice.”
The VIMS study is one of 14 projects to be conducted by onboard research teams during the upcoming cruise. Four other teams will be sending sensors to gather data for later analysis.
Other project participants hail from Stockholm University and the University of Gothenburg in Sweden; the Alfred Wegener Institute and University of Oldenburg in Germany; the University of Leeds and University College London in the United Kingdom; and the Bigelow Laboratory for Ocean Sciences, College of Charleston, University of California, University of Michigan, University of Washington and Villanova University in the United State.
Dr. Caroline Leck, Stockholm University professor and the expedition’s Swedish co-chief scientist, describes the voyage as “a logistical and technical challenge beyond the ordinary in inhospitable and inaccessible areas of the North Pole.”
She said the overall goal is “to better understand the important role of clouds in the Arctic climate system. We must rise to the challenge and carry out onsite studies into the link between life in the sea and cloud formations.”
Smith, a 40-year veteran of polar research, agrees the cruise won’t be easy.
“The challenges of working in the Arctic are many,” he said. “Even near the North Pole, ice concentrations have diminished so much in recent years that finding an appropriate floe will be difficult, even with satellite imagery. We also expect very foggy weather, which makes helicopter flights to additional sites difficult.”
Clouds, condensation, communities, chemistry and climate
Interactions between clouds, marine communities, ocean chemistry and climate are inherently complex and made even more so in polar regions by the presence of sea ice. Adding further complexity is that sea-ice cover in the Arctic Ocean is rapidly decreasing due to global warming.
Clouds play a key role in climate change because they can promote both cooling (by reflecting sunlight) and warming (by trapping outgoing heat energy). Which effect predominates depends on cloud abundance, distribution, height, shape and opacity — features that are themselves changing as Earth warms.
Changes in sea ice present similar complexities.
Adding even more complexity is that in order to form, clouds require tiny suspended particles. These “condensation nuclei” can be anything from dust specks to soot from a smokestack or forest fire.
Over ocean areas, the major sources of these “cloud seeds” are sulfurous chemicals released by single-celled phytoplankton during photosynthesis and growth. These marine algae, which inhabit sunlit surface waters worldwide, also occur in a less familiar habitat in polar regions — on the surface and inside tiny channels within floating sea ice.
This is where the VIMS team is focusing its studies.
“Our main research question,” said Smith, is “how ongoing ocean acidification caused by increased CO2 concentrations in seawater are influencing biological processes in the ice.”
Polar researchers generally expect that the decrease in Arctic sea ice will lead to a more productive ecosystem overall, as sunlight streams into previously ice-shaded water and wind-driven waves mix nutrients toward the surface.
“But,” said Shadwick, “impacts on ice-dependent biological communities are challenging to predict.”
Under current conditions, a single species of ice algae — the diatom Melosira arctica — accounts for almost half the primary production of organic matter in the Arctic Ocean.
But Dr. Klaus Valentin of the Alfred Wegener Institute warns that “nobody can predict whether Melosira will be a victim or a beneficiary of the melting sea ice.”
Valentin, who is not involved in the current study, said, “As the sea water gets warmer and the sun gets stronger, most algae grow better, but this may be completely different for the Melosira.”
One thing that sets Melosira and related ice algae apart is that they build skeletons of silica — largely resistant to the increasing ocean acidity that is already dissolving the shells or skeletons of corals, oysters and other sea creatures that instead use calcium carbonate. Indeed, the few studies done so far show that increases in ocean CO2 levels actually promote the growth of siliceous diatoms.
During the Oden cruise, Smith and Margolin will further test the effects of changing ocean acidity by exposing algae and bacteria collected from nearby ice floes to different concentrations of CO2 dissolved in seawater, and monitoring how it affects the organisms’ metabolism and growth.
Shadwick stresses that her team’s experimental results will help fill a significant gap in Arctic research.
“Our work will help quantify the sensitivity of ice-dependent algae and bacteria to changes in acidity, and also deliver new observations on how CO2 varies in space and time within the Arctic Ocean during late summer when sea ice is at a minimum,” she said.
“Our observations will add to a growing, but still very sparse dataset that will contribute to understanding natural variability and an already much altered baseline in the high Arctic.”