Deferred Judgment for Man Accused of Fighting at Route 17 Bar is your source for free news and information in Williamsburg, James City & York Counties.

York Sheriff's office vehicleA Gloucester man will have to wait until September for a judgment in a case that stems from a January bar fight in York County.

The court found sufficient evidence to find Jonathan Coates guilty of one count of unlawful wounding, but deferred a final decision in the case until a pre-sentence hearing, scheduled for Sept. 22.

With the deferred decision, the defense will be able to argue for a not guilty verdict.

“It’s a rare thing,” Assistant Commonwealth’s Attorney Jeremy Markle said of the deferred judgment.

The case stems from a January incident at the Cactus Bar on Route 17 in York County.

Witnesses told deputies with the York-Poquoson Sheriff’s Office Coates was “being unruly and trying to pick fights with patrons,” Lt. Dennis Ivey said in April.

When deputies arrived at the scene, they found a man with a puncture wound in his left cheek due to a tooth coming through the skin after a punch. The man required stitches for that injury, and also suffered a small laceration on the back of his head.

Coates was arrested March 23 after a two-month investigation.

An original charge of aggravated malicious wounding was reduced to unlawful wounding, a class 6 felony.

The charge carries a maximum penalty of five years in prison and a $2,500 fine.

Related Coverage: